Some of the biggest news in the green world last week was reactions to a study that show the possible adverse effects of bottles (and other products) made with bisphenol A, or BPA, the chemical used to make my beloved Nalgene bottles. This news hit home when I heard an interview on NPR with one of the study’s authors.
While I was aware that putting these bottles in the dishwasher (top-rack only) could lead to a breakdown and possible seepage of chemicals–which is why I would replace bottles every 6 to 12 months–this newest news is too dire to ignore. In fact, with Nalgene pulling all of its hard-plastic bottles from store shelves immediately, it’s time for me to pull my Nalgene bottles from my shelves, too.
As you know using a reusable water bottle is a smart step towards reducing disposable plastic water bottles in landfills, especially since some studies indicate that only about 10 to 20 percent of plastic water bottles actually make it to a recycling facility. The rest? They get dumped in landfills.
Surprisingly, TreeHugger hasn’t come out and damned Nalgene bottles, but instead offers some level-headed advice on what to do about preventing any possible BPA exposure in the future–and what kinds of products you should choose to remain BPA free.
I think what’s also important to point out is that not all Nalgene water bottles are worth worrying about. Check out this comparison chart on the Nalgene Choice website. It spells out for you which bottles contain BPA (yes to the polycarbonate, screw-top bottles that I use and pack in my kids’ lunch everyday–no more) and which don’t (the 32-ounce, green “Filter for Good” bottle that I’ve been using. That’s a huge relief).
I’ve heard that the best and safest reusable bottle you can use is one made from stainless steel. I’m thinking at this point, to be a smart and safe consumer, you should make sure that any reusable water bottle you choose says straight out that its BPA free. This is especially important if you’ve been using these bottles in your kids’ lunches, since recent studies have said that BPA may adversely affect youngsters the most.
What concerns me as well is this notion that BPA is in dental sealants, which both of my kids recently had applied to their 12-year molars, and the composite fillings I’ve got in my mouth. The American Dental Association says there’s no cause for concern. Nonetheless, I’ll have to give the dentist a call about all of this.
READ LEAH ON HOME GOES STRONG
Do you have a personal recommendation for a replacement non-leaching water bottle? I’m torn between Klean Kanteens and Siggs.
I really like that you brought this up in your blog. I know I heard something about it in the news, but really didn’t hear the whole story.
As an avid Nalgene bottle user I really find this story upsetting. I will have to admit I often used plastic water bottles, but a couple of years back stopped. Now, I find out that using Nalgene could be harmful.
I guess I just am not sure what to do now. You mentioned that metal bottles are the best. Do you have any recommendations?
Thanks again for bringing this up.
I’m currently researching replacement suggestions. I’ll post something soon! Thanks for writing.
Leah
I noticed your blog and thought I would offer a few suggestions. I too was a Nalgene fanatic but just ditched it for a Klean Kanteen, which I like much better. It’s easier to carry around and to drink out of (at least in my opinion). There are many other options out there too. You can check out my blog posting for some ideas and a link to a picture gallery from the Boston Globe with other suggestions: http://cleangreenmean.blogspot.com/2008/04/quick-and-easy.html
Good luck! And remeber, recycle the Nalgene!
Stacey:
All of the BPA Nalgene bottles went in recycling last week. I wouldn’t dare toss them in the trash, lest I be called a hypocrite. Thanks for the link. I’ll check it out.
Leah
After reading the latest news on plastic, I bought Klean Kanteens for our family. We like them very much. We got the loop tops which are probably not necessary unless you are packing in the wilderness. My daughter would prefer the flat top. The first time we used them, the water tasted a bit metalic but since then I don’t notice it. Love not buying the cases of water bottles.
We also stopped microwaving plastic. Bought some Anchor Hocking and Martha Stewart glass bowls with lids at KMart.
Both changes came to less than $100.
A company that we work with (Wellness Enterprises) is launching a new product in June – it’s tentatively called the Wellness H2.0 water bottle. The bottle is made of recycled plastic (non-leaching) and actually filters and enhances the water using coconut carbon, negative ions and volcanic minerals. I can post or send more info as i get it if anyone is interested.